Key lime pie in Suncoast South

41 restaurants list it, from $2.99 to $35. Towns: Boca Grande, Charlotte Harbor, Englewood, Grove City, Nokomis, North Port, Osprey, Placida, Port Charlotte, Punta Gorda, Sarasota, Venice, Venice downtown.

Each price is what the restaurant publishes on its own menu, repeated without adjustment. Restaurants are listed A to Z inside each town; nobody pays to be listed or to rank. Prices change — call before you go.

Not yet confirmed with the restaurant. This listing was collected in September 2026 from the restaurant’s own website or menu listing. It has not been confirmed with the restaurant by phone yet, so the hours, the prices and even whether it is open can be out of date. Call before you go.

Boca Grande

Keylime Bistro Boca Grande

Key Lime Pie · $8.00

Whole Key Lime Pie · $35.00

📞 (941) 964-0440

Scarpas Coastal

Key Lime pie · $11.00

📞 941-964-0806

Charlotte Harbor

Half Cracked Tiki Shack

Key Lime Slice · $11.75

📞 833-914-7300

Englewood

Beachcomber Trading Post Restaurant

Key Lime Pie · $8.00

📞 941-460-8580

Landy's

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 941-474-4292

Mako's Coastal Kitchen

Key Lime Pie · $7.00

📞 (941) 626-9765

Mango Bistro

Key West Key Lime Pie · $5.99

📞 941-681-3500

SandBar Tiki & Grille

KEY LIME PIE · $8.50

📞 941.460.8280

Wink's Old Town Grill

Key Lime Pie · $2.99

📞 941-474-7777

Grove City

Ken and Barb's Grove City Kitchen

KEY LIME TRIFLE · $7.99

📞 941-460-8999

Nokomis

Paradise Grill

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 (941) 786-1524

Pop's Sunset Grill

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 (941) 488-3177

North Port

Dubz BBQ

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 941-200-2636

The Bistro 3515

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 (941) 257-8036

Osprey

Casey Key Fish House

Key Lime Pie · $8.99

📞 941.966.1901

Local Pizza

KEY LIME TART · $8.00

📞 (941) 909-0743

Placida

Rum Bay Restaurant

KEY LIME PIE SLICE · $9.00

📞 (941) 697-0566

Smokin Jerry's Tiki Hut

KEY LIME PIE · $7.95

📞 (941) 697-0724

Port Charlotte

Chubby'z 2 Grill & Tavern

Key Lime Pie or Chocolate Brownie · $3.95

📞 (941) 613-0002

King's Roadhouse Bar & Grill

key lime pie · $6.99

📞 (941) 979-9294

Red Lobster

Key Lime Pie · $10.99

📞 (941) 625-7745

The Chef Thai Sushi Bar & Grill

Key Lime Pie · $4.95

📞 941-883-6800

The Twisted Fork

Key Lime Pie · $8.00

📞 (941) 235-3675

Punta Gorda

Leroy's Fish Shack

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 (941) 397-5005

Leroy's Southern Kitchen & Bar

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 (941) 505-2489

Peace River Seafood & Crab Shack

Anne Bonny Key Lime Pie · $6.95

📞 941-505-8440

Riviera Bar & Grill

Key Lime · $8.00

📞 (941) 639-2633

The Islands Kitchen & Cocktail House

Key Lime Cake · $10.00

📞 (941) 347-7991

TT's Tiki Bar

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 941-637-6770

Vic's Primo Pizza and Restaurant

Key lime Pie · $5.99

📞 941-621-4280

Village Brewhouse

Key Lime Pie · $8.00

📞 (941) 417-8764

Winesett House

Key Lime Pie · $8.00

Key Lime Cake · $12.00

📞 (941) 637-9477

Sarasota

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant

Key Lime Pie · $11.99

📞 (941) 263-8100

Venice

Bonefish Grill

Key Lime Pie · $11.90

📞 (941) 493-4180

Brewburgers

Key Lime Pie · $7.99

📞 (941) 477-0009

Brewburgers Backporch

Key Lime Pie · $7.99

📞 (941) 477-0006

Gold Rush BBQ

Key Lime Pie · $5.00

📞 (941) 483-3137

Pinchers

Signature Key Lime Pie · $6.00

📞 (941) 485-9196

Red Grouper Tavern

Key Lime Pie · $9.99

📞 (941) 483-3809

Sharky's On the Pier

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 941.488.1456

Venice downtown

T.J. Carney's Pub & Grille

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 941-480-9244

More dishes in Suncoast South

All dishes by area → · All restaurants → · Search the guide by dish →