CHEWZI.NET

‹ The guide

Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar

65 dishes with prices · Rosemary District · Greater Sarasota

Not yet confirmed with the restaurant. This listing was collected from the restaurant’s own website or menu listing. It has not been confirmed with the restaurant by phone yet, so the hours, the prices and even whether it is open can be out of date. Call before you go.

Not yet confirmed open. Call before you go.

Address
428 N Lemon Ave, Sarasota FL
Area
Rosemary District

📞 (941) 954-8688

Hours

Sunday11:30–21:00
Monday11:30–21:00
Tuesday11:30–21:00
Wednesday11:30–21:00
Thursday11:30–21:00
Friday11:30–21:00
Saturday11:30–21:00

Hours posted on their website: page headed "Summer Hours": Sun-Thu 11:30am-9pm; Fri-Sat 11:30am-9pm (read 2026-10-26; seasonal heading, confirm)

CHEWZI repeats these hours without adjustment and does not check them in real time — ring ahead if it matters.

Menu

Oysters

$17.00Pearls & Parm (half dozen)

baked with parmesan breadcrumbs, garlic butter, bacon, cayenne

$33.00Pearls & Parm (dozen)

baked with parmesan breadcrumbs, garlic butter, bacon, cayenne

Half dozen 13 / Dozen 26House Oysters on the Half Shell
MPSpecialty Oysters on the Half Shell

half dozen or dozen

$12.00Oyster Shooter Watershed

Absolut Tabasco, Bloody Mary mix, Tajin rim

$8.00Oyster Shooter Traditional

Tito's vodka shot and oyster

From the Steamer

$17.00Drunken Clams

white wine garlic broth, celery, onion, crostinis

$21.00Snow Crab

1/2 lb with drawn butter

$16.00Mussels Frites

white wine garlic broth, celery, onion, fries

$18.00Thai Mussels

coconut, curry, spices, fries

10 ct 15 / 20 ct 28Peel & Eat Shrimp

garlic butter or Old Bay

Set Sail

$16.00Key West Conch Fritters

housemade remoulade

$17.00Seafood Ceviche

freshest catch, citrus, cilantro, peppers, jalapeño

$17.00Crispy Calamari

banana peppers, garlic butter, spicy marinara

$18.00Two Fried Soft Shell Crabs

Lefty's sauce, grilled lemon

$11.00Fried Green Tomatoes

Cajun remoulade

$18.00Gulf Grouper Bites

housemade tartar sauce

$17.00Louisiana Gator Bites

housemade remoulade

$15.00Big Bad Shrimp

butterflied, panko-breaded, cocktail sauce

$12.00Smoked Fish Dip

saltine crackers

$7.00Lefty's Hush Pups

hot honey butter

$16.00Ahi Tuna Tartare

avocado, tropical salsa, wasabi, sriracha, tortilla chips

Harborside Handhelds

$17.00Soft Shell Crab BLT

bacon, lettuce, tomato, Lefty's sauce

MPGulf Grouper Sandwich

grilled, blackened or fried

$16.00Smash Burger Double Patty

American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, Lefty's sauce

MPMaine Lobster Rolls

Maine lobster meat, celery, onion, mayo, two split rolls

$17.00Tacos Chicken / Shrimp / Mahi

two flour tortillas, cabbage, pico de gallo, cilantro crema

$22.00Tacos Ahi Tuna

two flour tortillas, cabbage, pico de gallo, cilantro crema

MPTacos Gulf Grouper

two flour tortillas, cabbage, pico de gallo, cilantro crema

Po' Boys

$16.00Catfish Po' Boy

lettuce, tomato, pickle, remoulade

MPGulf Grouper Po' Boy

lettuce, tomato, pickle, remoulade

$17.00Shrimp Po' Boy

lettuce, tomato, pickle, remoulade

Market Signatures

$42.00Seafood Boil

snow crab, peel & eat shrimp, mussels, crawdads, andouille, corn, red potatoes

$28.00Seared Sesame Ahi Tuna

ponzu sauce, soba noodles

$45.00Snow Crab Legs

a full pound with corn and red potatoes

$32.00Steak Frites

10 oz skirt steak, chimichurri, fries

MPFresh Catch
MPSea Scallops

pan seared, white wine, lemon, shallots

MPGulf Grouper

grilled, blackened or fried

$30.00Atlantic Salmon

grilled or blackened, dill crema

From the Garden

$15.00Neptune Salad

romaine, red onion, cucumber, Kalamata olives, tomatoes, pepperoncini, feta

$13.00Lefty's Caesar Salad

romaine, croutons, parmesan, housemade Caesar

$14.00Dog House Salad

romaine, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, mixed cheese, croutons

$13.00The Wedge

iceberg, bleu cheese, tomatoes, red onion, bacon, balsamic glaze

Captain's Kettles

Cup 8 / Bowl 12Seafood Chowder

cream base with Gulf grouper and clams

Cup 6 / Bowl 10Red Beans & Rice

dirty rice, red beans, andouille, peppers, onions

Cup 9 / Bowl 13Lefty's Gumbo

alligator and pork sausage, chicken, dirty rice, okra

Crisp & Crunch

$28.00Watershed Platter

shrimp, bay scallops, white fish, tartar sauce

$26.00Gulf Platter

shrimp, gator bites, grouper bites, tartar sauce

$23.00Fish & Chips

beer battered white fish, tartar sauce

$24.00Fried Catfish Dinner

Cajun cornmeal dusted, hush puppies

$24.00Crispy Shrimp Platter

panko breaded, cocktail sauce

Galley Grains & Pasta

$35.00Downtown Seafood Pasta

lobster, scallops, shrimp, linguine, shallot garlic butter

$26.00Shrimp & Grits

jumbo Gulf shrimp, southern grits, peppers, andouille

$22.00Linguine with Clams

garlic, shallots, white wine butter sauce

$19.00Cajun Chicken Alfredo

cavatappi, bell peppers, onions, parmesan

Little Mariners

$13.00Fried Shrimp

12 and under

$11.00Fried Chicken Strips

12 and under

$12.00Fried Grouper Fingers

12 and under

$10.00Burger

12 and under, single patty

$9.00Buttered Cavatappi Noodles

12 and under

MPFresh Catch

12 and under

Sweets

$9.00Key Lime Pie
$12.00Double Layer Chocolate Cake
$12.00New York Style Cheesecake

Other restaurants in Rosemary District

Spice Station91 dishes on CHEWZIPazzo On Orange62 dishes on CHEWZIToasted Mango Cafe (Rosemary District)64 dishes on CHEWZIVino Bistro25 dishes on CHEWZI

Compare prices nearby

Burgers in Greater Sarasota · Cheesecake in Greater Sarasota · Fish and chips in Greater Sarasota · Fish tacos in Greater Sarasota · Grouper in Greater Sarasota · Key lime pie in Greater Sarasota · Oysters in Greater Sarasota · Salmon in Greater Sarasota

Open Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar in the CHEWZI guide → — search it by dish, compare it with others, and see what is open now.

What CHEWZI is

CHEWZI comes from a family that has spent four generations in hospitality — upscale hotel management and an executive role at Holiday Inn, thirty-five years in hotel operations and corporate Food & Beverage with Sheraton, and fifteen years as an executive chef. The fourth generation brought the technology.

There are plenty of ways to find a restaurant. Finding what you actually want to eat is harder than it should be. So CHEWZI publishes the full menu, with prices, and lets you search by the dish.

We repeat what a restaurant publishes. We do not invent an hour, a price, a dietary marking or a special. Where a restaurant publishes nothing, we say so instead of guessing. It is free, there is no account, and we take no commission from any restaurant, ever.

More about CHEWZI, and how to use it → · Get the app →

Listed free. CHEWZI takes no commission and nobody pays to be listed or to rank higher. Everything on this page was collected from what Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar publishes, or from a listing where the page says so, and has not yet been confirmed with the restaurant. Where nothing is published, this page says so. Read 26 Oct 2026. A restaurant can correct anything here with one email to post@chewzi.net.

© 2026 Charles Squires. CHEWZI™ and Whisker™ are trademarks of Charles Squires. Menus, prices and hours belong to each restaurant. Terms of use