CHEWZI.NET

‹ The guide

Key lime pie in Greater Sarasota

38 restaurants list it, from $5 to $14.99. Towns: Downtown Sarasota, East Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch, Longboat Key, Main Street, Rosemary District, Siesta Key, South Trail, Southside Village, SR 64, St. Armands & Lido, University Pkwy, UTC, Waterside.

Each price is what the restaurant publishes on its own menu, repeated without adjustment. Restaurants are listed A to Z inside each town; nobody pays to be listed or to rank. Prices change — call before you go.

Not yet confirmed with the restaurant. This listing was collected from the restaurant’s own website or menu listing. It has not been confirmed with the restaurant by phone yet, so the hours, the prices and even whether it is open can be out of date. Call before you go.

Downtown Sarasota

Duval's Fresh. Local. Seafood.

Key Lime Pie · $13.5

📞 (941) 312-4001

Mattison's City Grille

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 (941) 330-0440

Tamiami Tap

Key Lime Pie · $8.00

📞 (941) 500-3182

The Breakfast Company (Downtown Sarasota)

Key Lime Pie Pancakes · $14.99

📞 (941) 364-8767

East Sarasota

Kacey's Seafood & More (Fruitville)

Key Lime Pie · $7.95

📞 941-378-3644

Lakewood Ranch

Libby's Neighborhood Brasserie

Key Lime Pie · $10

📞 (941) 357-1570

Linger Lodge

FLORIDA KEY LIME PIE · $8

Key Lime Pie · $8

📞 (941) 755-2757

The Greyson

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 (941) 755-5050

Longboat Key

Chart House

Key Lime Pie · $12.00

📞 (941) 383-5593

Main Street

Delany's Public House

Key Lime Pie · $10

Key Lime Pie · $10

📞 (941) 222-1100

GROVE

Key Lime Meringue Pie · $10

📞 (941) 893-4321

Pinchers Lakewood Ranch

SIGNATURE KEY LIME PIE · $8.00

📞 941-900-3315

Remy's on Main

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 941-355-9391

Rosemary District

Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 (941) 954-8688

Siesta Key

Clayton's Siesta Grille

Clayton's Key Lime Pie · $12.00

📞 (941) 587-5525

Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 (941) 349-8697

Turtles on Little Sarasota Bay

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 (941) 346-2207

South Trail

Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria

Mini Key Lime Pie · $12.00

📞 (941) 536-1546

Roessler's Restaurant

Key Lime Pie · $9.00

📞 (941) 966-5688

Southside Village

Libby's Neighborhood Brasserie

Key Lime Pie · $10.00

📞 (941) 236-5826

Shakespeare's English Pub

Key Lime Pie · $6.75

📞 (941) 364-5938

SR 64

Extreme Pizza

Key Lime Pie · $11

📞 (941) 279-8200

Seasons 52 (Bradenton, SR 64)

KEY LIME PIE (1 MINI) · $5.00

📞 (941) 201-1136

St. Armands & Lido

Cha Cha Coconuts

Key West Key Lime Pie · $8.00

📞 (941) 388-3300

Columbia Restaurant

Key Lime Pie · $12.00

📞 (941) 388-3987

Tommy Bahama Restaurant (St. Armands)

Key Lime Pie · $12.00

📞 (941) 388-2888

University Pkwy

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant

Key Lime Pie · $11.99

📞 941-263-8100

Duffy's Sports Grill

Key Lime Pie · $9.99

Kacey's Seafood & More (University Pkwy)

Key Lime Pie · $7.95

📞 941-351-5515

Stottlemyer's Smokehouse

Key Lime Pie · $8.99

📞 (941) 312-5969

Tarpon Bay Grill & Tiki Bar

Mike's Key Lime Pie · $9

📞 (941) 893-5528

Tommy Bahama Marlin Bar

KEY LIME PIE · $7.00

📞 (941) 337-0568

UTC

Bonefish Grill

Key Lime Pie · $11.90

📞 (941) 360-3171

Ford's Garage

Key Lime Pie · $10.50

📞 941-803-3673

Post Kitchen & Bar

Key Lime Pie · $12.00

📞 (941) 259-4850

Seasons 52 (UTC)

Key Lime Pie (1 mini) · $5.00

📞 (941) 702-9652

The Breakfast Company

Key Lime Pie Pancakes · $8.99+

Key Lime Pie Waffle · $14.99

📞 (941) 210-4760

Waterside

Lucky Pelican Bistro

Key Lime Pie · $9.50

📞 (941) 907-0589

More dishes in Greater Sarasota

BurgersCheesecakeChicken parmesanChicken wingsChowderCoconut shrimpCrab cakesCuban sandwichEggs BenedictFilet mignonFish and chipsFish tacosFrench onion soupGrouperGrouper sandwichLobster bisqueLobster rollMahi-mahiMeatloafOmelettesOystersPad ThaiPancakesPatty meltPizzaPrime ribReubenRibeye steakSalmonScallopsShrimp and gritsShrimp tacos

All dishes by area → · All restaurants → · Search the guide by dish →

© 2026 Charles Squires. CHEWZI™ and Whisker™ are trademarks of Charles Squires. Menus, prices and hours belong to each restaurant. Terms of use