CHEWZI.NET

‹ The guide

Mahi-mahi in Greater Sarasota

29 restaurants list it, from $12 to $36. Towns: Bee Ridge, Downtown Sarasota, East Bradenton, East Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch, Main Street, Rosemary District, Siesta Key, Southside Village, SR 64, St. Armands & Lido, University Park, University Pkwy, UTC, Waterside.

Each price is what the restaurant publishes on its own menu, repeated without adjustment. Restaurants are listed A to Z inside each town; nobody pays to be listed or to rank. Prices change — call before you go.

Not yet confirmed with the restaurant. This listing was collected from the restaurant’s own website or menu listing. It has not been confirmed with the restaurant by phone yet, so the hours, the prices and even whether it is open can be out of date. Call before you go.

Bee Ridge

Evie's Tavern on the Range

Mahi Mahi Protein Plate · $17.99

Mahi-Mahi Sandwich · $15.99

📞 (941) 377-9300

Downtown Sarasota

Cask & Ale

Mahi-Mahi or Shrimp · $15

📞 (941) 685-9300

O'Leary's Tiki Bar & Grill

Mahi Reuben · $18.25

Mahi Mahi · $18.5

📞 (941) 203-4771

Patrick's 1481

Mediterranean Mahi Ciabatta · $20.00+

📞 (941) 955-1481

East Bradenton

Takos Cantina

Mahi Mahi · $24.00

📞 941-201-6594

Wheat + Water Italian Kitchen

Mahi Siciliano · $28.00

Side Mahi · $12.00

📞 (941) 216-3562

East Sarasota

Kacey's Seafood & More (Fruitville)

Mahi Reuben · $19.95

Mahi · $27

Cajun Mahi Salad · $23.95

+1 more on its menu

📞 941-378-3644

Lakewood Ranch

The Greyson

Mahi Bites · $17.50

Mahi Mahi · $22.00

📞 (941) 755-5050

Main Street

Ed's Tavern (Main Street)

Mahi-Mahi · $15.00

Mahi-Mahi Bites - NEW! · $17.00

📞 (941) 907-0400

Peculiar Pub

Mahi Reuben (GFA) · $24

📞 (941) 822-8131

Pinchers Lakewood Ranch

MAHI MAHI (Regular Order) · $27.00

MAHI MAHI (Lil' Less) · $20.00

MAHI MAHI SANDWICH · $19.00

📞 941-900-3315

Remy's on Main

KOREAN SEASAME & CHILI ROASTED MAHI MAHI · $26.00

📞 941-355-9391

Rosemary District

Toasted Mango Cafe (Rosemary District)

Blackened Mahi Wrap · $15.99

📞 (941) 388-7728

Siesta Key

Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village

Blackened Mahi Bites · $17.50

Tropical Glazed Mahi Sandwich · $22.00

📞 (941) 349-8697

Lobster Pot

Mahi · $24.00

📞 (941) 349-2323

The Old Salty Dog

Captain's Plate with Mahi · $30.00

📞 (941) 349-0158

Toasted Mango Cafe (Siesta Key South Village)

Blackened Mahi Wrap · $15.99

📞 (941) 552-6485

Turtles on Little Sarasota Bay

Mahi Mahi Sandwich · $21.00

Coconut Crusted Mahi Mahi · $21.00

Coconut Crusted Mahi-Mahi · $16.99

+1 more on its menu

📞 (941) 346-2207

Southside Village

Shakespeare's English Pub

Mahi Mahi Sandwich · $17.25

Mahi Mahi Salad · $16.95

📞 (941) 364-5938

SR 64

Ed's Tavern (State Road 64)

MAHI-MAHI · $15.00

MAHI-MAHI BITES - NEW! · $17.00

📞 (941) 329-1010

St. Armands & Lido

Cha Cha Coconuts

Key West Mahi Sandwich · $20.00

Tropical Mahi-Mahi · $22.00

📞 (941) 388-3300

Columbia Restaurant

Mahi-Mahi "Cayo Hueso" · $32.00

Mahi-Mahi "Varadero" · $36.00

📞 (941) 388-3987

University Park

Anna Maria Oyster Bar

Mahi Mahi · $24.00

📞 941-491-2662

University Pkwy

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant

Parmesan-Crusted Mahi Mahi · $33.99

Grilled Mahi Sandwich · $17.99

📞 941-263-8100

Kacey's Seafood & More (University Pkwy)

Mahi Reuben · $19.95

Mahi · $27

Cajun Mahi Salad · $23.95

+1 more on its menu

📞 941-351-5515

Tarpon Bay Grill & Tiki Bar

Blackened Mahi Bowl · $25

Mahi Plate · $30

📞 (941) 893-5528

UTC

PopStroke Sarasota

Blackened Mahi Wrap · $20

📞 (941) 500-9495

Waterside

Deep Lagoon Seafood

Mahi Mahi · $26

Tropical Mahi · $29

📞 941-877-2234

Lucky Pelican Bistro

Mahi Poblano · $29

Lucky Mahi · $34

Mahi · $29

📞 (941) 907-0589

More dishes in Greater Sarasota

BurgersCheesecakeChicken parmesanChicken wingsChowderCoconut shrimpCrab cakesCuban sandwichEggs BenedictFilet mignonFish and chipsFish tacosFrench onion soupGrouperGrouper sandwichKey lime pieLobster bisqueLobster rollMeatloafOmelettesOystersPad ThaiPancakesPatty meltPizzaPrime ribReubenRibeye steakSalmonScallopsShrimp and gritsShrimp tacos

All dishes by area → · All restaurants → · Search the guide by dish →

© 2026 Charles Squires. CHEWZI™ and Whisker™ are trademarks of Charles Squires. Menus, prices and hours belong to each restaurant. Terms of use